View Our New Jersey Popup Shop Event Calendar

Mystery Bags

Handmade mystery bags filled with spooky, cozy, and chaotic surprises. Each one includes unique art, witchy decor, and collectible gifts for anyone who loves something unexpected.

12 products

Jersey Girl Mystery Bag - The Ultimate Jersey Girl Gift 🎀

$50.00 $75.00 On Sale

Cozy Nights In Mystery Bag - Slippers Size 6.5-7.5

$30.00 $60.00 On Sale

It's just a bunch of hocus pocus Mystery bag

$30.00 $43.00 On Sale

Fueled by Coffee & Crappy Drivers Mystery Bag

$20.00 $37.00 On Sale

Spooky Babe Mystery Bag - SIZE LARGE

$50.00 $78.00 On Sale

Scary Until Coffee Mystery Bag

$25.00 $34.00 On Sale

Trick or Trinkets Mini Mystery Bag

$15.00 $28.00 On Sale

Queer & Coffinated Mystery Bag - LGBT Fundraiser

$25.00 $35.00 On Sale

Moonlit Mischief Mystery Bag

$15.00 $25.00 On Sale

Do you like Scary Movies? Mystery Bag

$35.00 $55.00 On Sale

Trick or Trinkets Mystery Bag

$25.00 $40.00 On Sale

Mystery Bag - Dead Tired

$25.00 $32.00 On Sale

You Might Also Like

handmade NJ floral pattern rainbow sticker

Spooky Haunting Designs